Only the Beautiful by Susan Meissner

I enjoy Susan Meissner’s writing, so I was thrilled to get this book via Net Galley. I absolutely LOVED this story (will be in my top ten of 2023 I’m sure). It’s been a long time since a book has moved me to tears but the ending of this novel did. I loved the character of Rosie and I connected with her as she was growing up in Sonoma. (If you know me, you know I grew up in nearby Napa). Her story is so tragic and yet I don’t think it’s all that rare or improbable.

Here’s the overview:

Description

A Best Historical Fiction of Spring Pick by Amazon, PopSugar, AARP, and BookBub!

A heartrending story about a young mother’s fight to keep her daughter, and the terrible injustice that tears them apart, by the USA Today bestselling author of The Nature of Fragile Things and The Last Year of the War.

California, 1938—When she loses her parents in an accident, sixteen-year-old Rosanne is taken in by the owners of the vineyard where she has lived her whole life as the vinedresser’s daughter. She moves into Celine and Truman Calvert’s spacious house with a secret, however—Rosie sees colors when she hears sound. She promised her mother she’d never reveal her little-understood ability to anyone, but the weight of her isolation and grief prove too much for her. Driven by her loneliness she not only breaks the vow to her mother, but in a desperate moment lets down her guard and ends up pregnant. Banished by the Calverts, Rosanne believes she is bound for a home for unwed mothers. But she soon finds out she is not going to a home of any kind, but to a place that seeks to forcibly take her baby – and the chance for any future babies – from her.

Austria, 1947—After witnessing firsthand Adolf Hitler’s brutal pursuit of hereditary purity—especially with regard to “different children”—Helen Calvert, Truman’s sister, is ready to return to America for good. But when she arrives at her brother’s peaceful vineyard after decades working abroad, she is shocked to learn what really happened nine years earlier to the vinedresser’s daughter, a girl whom Helen had long ago befriended. In her determination to find Rosanne, Helen discovers a shocking American eugenics program—and learns that that while the war had been won in Europe, there are still terrifying battles to be fought at home.

Rosie ends up being brought to what is now called the Sonoma Developmental Center, but what was then a State Hospital for those with mental illness. And the whole storyline about eugenics and forced sterilization is true and so disconcerting. I was oddly reminded of a movie I watched once on a flight to Europe about the Magdalene Laundries and from which I don’t think I have yet recovered. The absolute lack of respect for Rosie’s intellect, her wishes, her baby, and her body was quite unsettling. Additionally, Rosie has synesthesia, where she “hears in color”. This trait causes others to be suspicious of her.

Rosie’s story is so terrible and yet I know that it was the story of more than one unwed teen mother years ago. Meanwhile, the novel has the parallel story of Helen who lives and works as a nanny in Europe during the rise of Hitler and WWII. Of course, eugenics was a part of the Nazi regime and we are reminded of the horrific atrocities many innocent people suffered at their hands. One of my favorite interactions in the book (which I can’t cite directly as it’s on my kindle and too hard to locate) was when Helen is arguing with a Nazi officer and when he says “You wonder how I am able to play God?” and she responds, “No. God would not harm these children. He would love them.” This story is haunting but it shows the importance of not being a bystander and just letting things happen. Rosie’s life could have been much less tragic if someone had stepped in to do the right thing; and Helen dedicated her life to helping others who needed help, thus making a difference.

So two thumbs up from me on this one!

And here’s a picture of the real place that the protagonist was sent to:

And speaking of places like this, here’s a picture of the Napa State Hospital a town away where I grew up. It doesn’t look like this anymore but I was reading that many of the patients there were there because they were homeless or struggled with alcoholism. Imagine being driven up to this place.